iDrive vs Backblaze: Which Cloud Backup Actually Deserves Your Money?

If a hard drive has never died on you, the iDrive vs Backblaze debate probably feels academic. If it has, you know the feeling. One Sunday night my laptop went black without warning, taking three years of family photos, five years of tax records, and every client file from my side business down with it.

The repair shop recovered about 60% of the drive. The rest is gone. Permanently.

So I got serious about cloud backup. These past two years I’ve run iDrive and Backblaze side by side, iDrive across my family’s devices, Backblaze on my video editing machine, with deliberate crash-style recovery drills on both. A backup you’ve never tested is a guess, and I wanted data.

This is the comparison I wish I’d found back then. It’s also the matchup BriskPick readers email us about most, so let’s settle it.

## The Short Version

– **iDrive wins for most households and small businesses.** One plan covers unlimited devices, plus disk imaging, mobile backup, and file syncing. Budget roughly $52 to $70 a year for 2TB to 5TB, with aggressive first-year discounts.
– **Backblaze wins for one computer loaded with data.** $99 a year buys genuinely unlimited backup for a single machine. Video editors and photographers, that’s your pick.
– Setup takes five minutes with Backblaze. iDrive takes a weekend to learn, then hands you far more control.
– Both offer private-key encryption, and both survived my real-world restore tests.
– **My setup:** Backblaze on the data-hungry editing rig, iDrive for everything else. Total cost: about $170 a year. Cheap insurance.

## iDrive vs Backblaze at a Glance

## iDrive Review: What It Does Well (and Where It Annoys Me)

I run iDrive on my desktop, my wife’s laptop, both of our phones, and a small NAS with some fiddly setup. All of it draws from a single 5TB plan. That flexibility is iDrive’s killer feature, and no competitor at this price matches it.

### What iDrive does well

– **Unlimited devices per account.** PCs, Macs, iPhones, Android phones, external drives. Everything pulls from one storage pool.
– **Disk imaging.** You can clone an entire drive, OS and all, for bare-metal restores. Mine saved me a full weekend when my desktop SSD failed.
– **Snapshots and versioning.** iDrive keeps up to 30 previous versions of every file. That’s genuine ransomware protection, not a marketing line.
– **IDrive Express.** They physically ship you a drive for fast initial uploads or huge restores. On personal plans it’s often free once a year.
– **Built-in file syncing.** Works like a basic Dropbox alongside the backup side.
– **A free 10GB tier.** Forever. Test it with zero commitment.

### Where iDrive falls short

– **To be frank, the desktop app looks its age.** Menus everywhere, icons from another decade. Powerful, but cluttered, and I still open the wrong panel half the time.
– **Slower restores in my testing.** Pulling 200GB back took nearly two days. Backblaze finished the same job overnight.
– **The learning curve is real.** Budget an hour of YouTube tutorials before you feel confident configuring it.
– **Storage caps bite.** My 4TB of video work would eat most of a 5TB plan on its own.

Try iDrive’s free 10GB plan here. It’s the easiest way to see if the interface makes sense to you before paying a cent.

## Backblaze Review: Set It and Forget It

Backblaze lives on my editing laptop, which carries roughly 4TB of video projects and growing. In two years it has never once made me think about it. That’s the entire point.

### What Backblaze does well

– **Truly unlimited storage.** Back up 500GB or 15TB, the price stays $99 a year.
– **Five-minute setup.** Install, sign in, done. Sensible defaults handle the rest.
– **Fast, unthrottled uploads.** It saturated my ~100 Mbps upload line while iDrive hovered around 40 Mbps until I tweaked its throttle settings. When your first upload is 4TB, that gap matters.
– **External drives included.** Plug in any USB drive and it gets protected automatically. One catch: reconnect each drive at least every 30 days, or those files drop out of the backup set.
– **Restore Return Refund.** They’ll mail you a 128GB flash drive for $99, or up to an 8TB hard drive for $189. Send either back within 30 days and you get a full refund.
– **Forever Version History.** An optional add-on at +$2/month keeps old and deleted files indefinitely. Worth it if you’re the type who overwrites something and notices a month later. Ask me how I know.

### Where Backblaze falls short

– **One computer per subscription.** Three machines means $297 a year. My family alone would need four licenses.
– **No disk imaging.** You get your files back, but not a bootable system.
– **No phone backup.** The mobile app only lets you view and download what’s already in the cloud, and honestly, it’s a bit clunky.
– **No NAS backup.** Network drives are excluded, period. This alone ruled it out for one of my setups.
– **Default exclusions.** It quietly skips some system and application files unless you dig into settings. Review that list on day one.

Check Backblaze pricing here. The 15-day trial doesn’t even ask for a credit card.

## So Which One Gets Your Money?

There’s no single best cloud backup service. It comes down to one question: how many devices are you protecting?

One machine, tons of data? Backblaze. Unlimited storage and five-minute setup are hard to beat at $99 a year, and the Restore Return Refund program makes big restores painless.

A household, a small business, phones included? iDrive. One plan, unlimited devices, disk imaging, syncing. The app is uglier and restores run slower, but the flexibility justifies both flaws.

Some people recommend buying Backblaze licenses for the whole family. I think that’s bad advice once you hit two or three computers. The math collapses fast.

Can’t decide? Do what I did and run both. My combined bill sits around $170 a year, which is less than I once paid to recover 60% of a dead drive. That math wasn’t hard.

Leave a Comment Cancel reply